Hon. David Hunter – Alameda County Superior Court
Consumer Legal Remedies Act
Intentional Misrepresentation/Concealment of Material Facts
Plaintiff, MaryAnn Williamson
Daniel L. Casas, Esq. (Casas Riley & Simonian, LLP – Los Altos, CA)
Defendant, BMW of Fremont
Elizabeth L. Kolar, Esq. (Kolar & Associates- Santa Ana, CA)
Plaintiff, MaryAnn Williamson purchased a “certified pre-owned” BMW X5 in January 2004. Plaintiff alleged that the car was never properly CPO certified and/or should not have been CPO certified because of alleged pre-existing engine problems. BMW of Fremont denied Plaintiff’s allegations.
Defense verdict in favor of BMW of Fremont plus attorneys fees and costs against Plaintiff and in favor of the dealership in the amount of $9,500.